By Robert Haugh
Santa Clara pizza lovers have another reason to brag.
A Slice of New York has been named one of DoorDash’s top local pizza spots in America for 2026.
DoorDash released its “Battle of the Slices” list for National Pizza Month, highlighting 40 small and medium-sized pizza restaurants across the country.
A Slice of New York was one of just 10 restaurants selected in the entire Western United States.
DoorDash based its selections on customer data from September 2025 through September 2026. Restaurants had to have fewer than 10 locations, at least 1,000 DoorDash reviews and some of the highest average customer ratings.
A Slice of New York has a San Jose mailing address at 3443 Stevens Creek Blvd., but the restaurant describes itself as “a Santa Clara business with a San Jose address.”
The restaurant was founded in 2006 by New York native and Santa Clara business leader Kirk Vartan.

In 2017, it became the South Bay’s first retail worker cooperative.
A Slice of New York celebrated its 20th anniversary in September. They opened an expanded space next door with additional seating and beer service.
Six other Bay Area pizza restaurants made the cut: Blue Line Pizza and Luigi’s Pizza & Pasta in Campbell; Golden Boy Pizza, Little Star Pizza and Outta Sight in San Francisco; and Zachary’s Chicago Pizza in Oakland.
The list suggests Bay Area pizza can hold its own against more famous pizza regions such as New York, New Jersey, Philadelphia and Chicago.
According to Door Dash, pepperoni remained America’s most popular topping. And pineapple was ordered more often than olives, bacon, chicken or ham.
Congrats to Kirk and the Co-op! Great pizza! (Serious praise from an ex-New Yorker)
The best Pizza in the area!